Thursday, July 17, 2008

Baby Gear Review: Boppy vs. My Breast Friend

Lennon or McCartney. Coke or Pepsi. Brenda or Kelly. Ginger or Mary Anne. Chrissy or Cindy. Life's most important choices and debates that will never get solved... And then came the nursing pillows. The Boppy vs. The Breast Friend. Kind of the Hatfields and McCoys of baby gear.

We, unfortunately, were swayed by the Boppy crowd. This is fine horse shoe shaped pillow with a wide array of fashion covers. That's where it ends. This thing, for us anyway, has proved useless as a feeding aid. The concept is simple and thus the Boppy is the simplest solution. Wrap the pillow around your waist, lay child on pillow, attach child to boob and you have suckling bliss. Not.so.much.

The faults are many--the pillow is rounded on all sides, thus there is no platform to lay the child on. There is nothing that holds the pillow to mother thus there is nothing preventing it from detaching nor any ability for mother to shift in concert with the device.

I'm quite certain that in an idealized situation, where mother is in the exact right position, with ideal posture the pillow provides the requisite cushioning for between mother's lap and the child as that's all that you'd need. Such and idealized environment might be a glider chair which the nice folks at Target have delayed yet again from shipping to us--but that's a whole 'nother post. The limited support, stability and positions limit feeding options and flexibility and have rendered this device useless to us. It would make a very nice travel head rest pillow thing for a very large-headed individual though. Turns out the folks at Boppy seem to agree...the image to the left is a "product shot" from the Boppy home page. No mother, no breastfeeding but boy the cute baby looks happy in a cute little chair/pillow.

At the apex of our hatred for the Boppy we were at a loss when Zeke'sMom dropped by for a visit and offered up her used but no-longer-used My Breast Friend. The alternative to the Boppy in this holy war of breastfeeding furniture. A day later, Zeke'sMom came back with unit and life changed. The goal is identical to the Boppy, to provide a place for child to rest while enjoying what daddy no longer has access to--mommy's mammaries. However everything the Boppy is not, My Breast Friend is. First, it straps on with a simple buckle and adjustable belt. Second it has a firm AND flat surface conducive to holding the child stable. With these tow, we end up with a surface that moves as mother moves. Finally, the unit wraps completely around the torso with an added unit for back support. The result is that mom can feed in ideal surfaces, in bed, even standing up.

Like the Boppy, the unit features interchangeable fashion covers that are machine washable. Unlike the Boppy, there's a whole heck of a lot more to it than that.

I'm sure there are others out there who love the Boppy. We heard from a number of them and they convinced us that it was the best. I'm not calling them wrong, just different. I've laid out the reasons the Breast Friend is our new best friend (come on! I had to pay some homage to a terribly kitchy name) and why it gets the the Captain Suburbia Seal of Approval.

Saturday, July 5, 2008

Breast over Brest

In what will likely be one of the first of many disappointments for Payton, there is no Versus Network on the channel line-up at Lucille Packard Children's Hospital. Thus, the roll out of this year's Tour de France from Brest will be missed. It's a shame. I'd been prepping her for some time to get here early, which she did, so that she could see Stage 1. You see, instead of the typical Prolouge time trial that normally starts the race, the wacky French decided to make the maiden stage a road race with no time bonuses. First man over the line get the Yellow Jersey. But, no Vs. at the hospital. They have six channels of closed circuit TV which detail how to change diapers, etc. but no Tour. Come on! We've got nurses to change the diapers, we can figure it out later.

Oh well, for today and for her first tour, I'm sure Payton will be happy with breast instead of Brest. Daddy set it to record and would watch it later.

Friday, July 4, 2008

Right on Time

Like her mom, it's clear that my daughter believes, "if it's worth doing, it's worth doing on time". Right on her due date, our daughter ensured we'd have "fireworks" this year even if we were in the hospital.

Welcome to the world our little miracle. I love you already.

Payton Alexandra Jones
July 4, 2008 6:51pm
7 pounds, 8 ounces
20 inches long